I love Photoshop. I use it almost every day, and I’ve been using it since at least 1994. It really is a great program. And I fully realize it’s a program for professionals, which means a lot of it is optimized for efficient workflows for professionals, as opposed to being optimized for a shallow learning curve for new users.
But for the last few versions of Photoshop I’ve been driven crazy by what appears to be an oversight by the Photoshop developers in how their vector art tools work. The problem is not entirely apparent until it’s been seen in a real situation, so let’s walk through one.
The problem
Here’s a clipping of the image for my blog and homepage. The entire image was done in Photoshop, and a lot of it is done with Photoshop’s Vector tools. I’ve simplified the document to isolate just a few elements, in order to make things easier to explain. Here you can see we’ve got three vector art layers:

The problem I’m running into is with Photoshop’s two vector selection tools, the Path Selection Tool and the Direct Selection Tool. These two tools are used for manipulating control points on vector shapes, and they have an auto-layer-select function built into them that is flawed. Let’s say I’m trying to select and manipulate the points in the upper-left serif in the H logotype. I can use the Direct Selection Tool to do so, and if I click inside of the H or directly on the points, I’m okay:

But if I accidentally click outside of the H and on one of the purple hexagons, Photoshop automatically selects the hexagon layer:
Read the rest of this entry